top of page
Search

OUTCOME OF JUDICIAL REVIEW (JR) INVESTIGATION

Writer: Residents Against Clouds Hill Farm Development
Residents Against Clouds Hill Farm Development
Nov 3
2 min read

Following the issue of EBC’s final decision on the Clouds Hill Farm application, the RACHFD action group recently appointed a specialist planning barrister to consider our ability to successfully pursue a (JR).  

 

His advice was that given the very high bar set by the courts a JR is unlikely to be successful and we have therefore concluded that it wouldn’t make sense to progress the matter further. 

 

In addition to the advice that the likelihood of success in a JR application was low, we also discussed the likely outcomes if it were successful and the conclusion was that in the current circumstances, of which more below, it is likely that the application would ultimately succeed, especially given the fact that large applications can now be called in for review by the government. A case of potentially winning a battle but losing the war. 

 

Counsel agreed with the key criticisms that we and FEDORA have made during the process and didn’t think anything had been overlooked. Counsel noted the continuing errors made by the Surrey County Highways Authority in their work; commented on the ill-advised conduct and undesirable remarks of some members of the Planning Committee; and agreed that the planning officers had reached a conclusion on the sustainability of the site that many others would not have. By any common sense measures this site is not desirable from the perspective of ease of access to key facilities, as no doubt future residents will find.  

 

However, the courts will only permit a review of a decision if they can be persuaded that the conclusions reached were “so unreasonable” as to justify the court’s involvement. Counsel, who has extensive experience of working both for and against applicants, was clear that these circumstances did not pass this test. An important element of this assessment is that the law and policy give planning officers significant latitude when interpreting and applying planning polices and guidance. A range of factors can be taken into account and undoubtedly one is the dire shortfall in home building in Elmbridge compared to targets coupled with the pressure from national government to build.  

 

LOOKING FORWARD   


Looking forward, there is still a need to review and robustly challenge the forthcoming detailed planning application that will be submitted and to hold the developer and planning authorities to account during the 4-year construction phase to ensure they comply with relevant constraints and conditions. 

 

FEDORA will take on this role on using a combination of in-house experience and external experts where necessary. 

 

In light of this we have decided that any surplus monies from our fund-raising efforts will be transferred to FEDORA so that they draw upon them as necessary linked to these subsequent activity phases. 

 

Lastly, thank you to all our generous donors who helped us in no small way to mount a robust challenge to the CHF development. Well founded challenges like ours serve to hold planning functions to higher standards than would otherwise be the case and also send a message to other developers that they can’t expect Oxshott to simply roll over! 

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page